Reporting Issues with Mercurial

Are you having a bad experience with Mercurial or with hg.mozilla.org? Read on to learn how to report it and (hopefully) get it resolved.

Mercurial and Mozilla

The Mercurial project cares about Mozilla because the Firefox repository is one of the largest open source Mercurial repositories both in terms of repository size and number of users. Because of that scale, Mozillians tend to notice issues with Mercurial before others. As such, the Mercurial project is very keen to learn about and address the problems Mozillians may have.

How to Report Issues

With hg.mozilla.org

Notice something weird on hg.mozilla.org (including performance problems)? Please file a bug against Developer Services :: hg.mozilla.org.

If you want to talk with someone before filing a bug, hop in to #vcs on irc.mozilla.org. That is a low traffic channel and your question should be answered eventually.

With Core Mercurial

Found a bug in Mercurial? Have a performance concern? File a bug in Mercurial’s Bugzilla. Choose the Mercurial component if you are unsure what component to use.

Before filing bugs, ensure you are using the latest Mercurial release. If not, the first thing people will ask you is to try to reproduce with the latest release.

When filing bugs, practice good bug filing etiquite and try to include steps to reproduce.

Tip

Many Mercurial developers have a copy of mozilla-central for performance testing. Bug reports that reference mozilla-central (or any public repository for that matter) are acceptable.

If you are unsure whether something is a bug, hop in to #mercurial on the Freenode IRC network and ask around. Or, post to one of the Mercurial mailing lists.

With a Mozilla Extensions

Mozillians have authored a handful of Mercurial extensions. If you find a bug in one, file a bug against that extension’s Bugzilla component. These components all exist in the Developer Services product on bugzilla.mozilla.org.

Before filing bugs, ensure you are using the latest Mercurial release and that your version-control-tools repo (the repo containing most of the extensions) is fully up to date. Otherwise, you may be reporting a bug that’s been fixed already.

For the Impatient

In a hurry and don’t want to spend the time to report a proper bug? Ping gps on irc.mozilla.org and he’ll do the right thing if he can.

Ways to Make Bug Reports More Useful

All Mercurial commands accept the following options, which may prove useful when reporting bugs:

--debug
When this option is present, Mercurial will print debug info to output. This may aid debugging hangs and other issues.
--traceback
When this option is present, Mercurial will dump its execution stack when aborted. Using –traceback plus ctrl+c is a good way to see which method is spinning the CPU.
--profile
Profile Mercurial execution and print a summary after execution. This is useful for debugging performance issues to see where Mercurial is spending most of its time.

Including the output with one or more of these options can make bugs reports (especially performance issues) much more meaningful.

Another tool to aid debugging is the blackbox extension. Simply add the following to your hgrc:

[extensions]
blackbox =

[blackbox]
track = *
maxsize = 10 MB
maxfiles = 2

A .hg/blackbox.log file will now exist in each repository. This log will capture forensic details that may aid debugging and performance analysis.

How Not to Report Issues

Please do not complain about issues (e.g. on #developers) without telling someone who can do something about it. Otherwise, you have effectively complained to a black hole and your problems will likely persist because someone empowered to do something about them doesn’t know of them.

If you see something, file something! Don’t be just a complainer: be an enabler.